Make it your character's problem: the best acting advice I ever got

Halfway through a four-month run at the National Theatre, I woke up with a bad back. No warning, no inciting incident, just inexplicably stiff and, most worryingly of all, obviously affecting my movement.

The play was Maxim Gorky's Children of the Sun, directed by the late Howard Davies and set in Russia at the turn of the twentieth century. I couldn't stand up straight. I was slow to sit down and slower to get up again. And I spent the hours before the show in a quiet panic, working out how I was going to hide all of this from an audience of 800 people, eight times a week.

As we did our individual warmups on stage in the lead up to the half hour call, my friend Paul Higgins noticed I wasn't my usual sprightly self. Paul is one of the finest actors I've ever worked with, and without question the most creative and spontaneous. I told him my problem.

His reply was immediate, and his instinct was flawless.

"Well, they had bad backs in Russia at the turn of the century."

Then he spelled it out.

"Make it your character's problem."

Stop hiding it

What Paul meant was simple. I was spending all my energy trying to disguise a weakness, and the disguise was the thing that would give me away. An actor straining to look normal looks like an actor straining. But a man in 1900s Russia with a bad back? That's just a man. It's a detail. It might even be an interesting one.

The moment I stopped fighting it, the problem shrank. It became part of where I was, rather than something I was pretending wasn't there.

It works far beyond a bad back

I've used Paul's advice ever since, and I've found it works on much more than the physical.

When I read a script and think I'm too young for this part, I ask: maybe the character feels too young for what they're doing.

When I think I'm not physically imposing enough, maybe the character feels that too.

When I think I'm not attractive enough, or I don't have the experience to pull this off, maybe that's exactly the character's problem. Plenty of people in real life are doing jobs they feel too young, too inexperienced or too ordinary for. That's not a flaw in the performance. That's the truth of the person.

The insecurity stops being something I have to overcome before I can do the work. It becomes part of the work.

What this means at work

I think this is one of the most useful tools I know, and not just for actors.

Think about the last time you walked into an interview, a pitch or a big meeting carrying something you were anxious about. Maybe you were younger than everyone else in the room. Maybe you'd come from a different industry. Maybe your CV had a gap, or you didn't have the qualification everyone else seemed to have.

Most of us try to hide those things. We hope no one notices. And just like an actor with a bad back, the effort of hiding shows. We get stiff, guarded and a little less ourselves.

The alternative isn't to confess every worry the moment you walk in. It's to acknowledge the thing, to yourself first, and then decide how it becomes part of your story:

  • Younger than the room? You bring fresh eyes, and you know you've had to work harder to get here.
  • Changing careers? You see the industry the way its customers do, not the way insiders do.
  • Short on experience? You're hungry, you learn fast, and you'll say plainly what you don't yet know.
  • Worried you're not the obvious fit? Maybe that's precisely why they need you.

None of that is spin. It's the same move Paul taught me: stop pretending the thing isn't there, and let it become part of who you are in that moment.

What this means for leaders

This isn't only advice for the person in the interview chair. It matters just as much for the people running the organisation.

Psychologists Pauline Clance and Suzanne Imes named the "impostor phenomenon" back in 1978: the persistent feeling, often among highly capable people, of not being good enough for the role. Almost everyone recognises it, including plenty of senior leaders. Most of them handle it the way I handled my bad back: by hiding it, at great effort.

That costs organisations more than it seems. A leader who can never admit a gap teaches their team that gaps must be hidden. Problems surface late, people stop asking for help, and mistakes get covered rather than fixed. Amy Edmondson's research at Harvard on psychological safety shows that teams who feel safe to admit uncertainty and errors learn faster and perform better.

The leaders who build that safety are rarely the ones who seem flawless. They're the ones who can say, in effect, "this is new to me too, and here's how we'll handle it". They've made it their character's problem, and in doing so, given everyone else permission to do the same.

The audience can tell

Audiences, interview panels and clients are remarkably good at sensing when someone is hiding something. They're just as good at warming to someone who seems comfortable in their own skin, stiff back and all.

So the next time you're worried about the thing you think will let you down, try taking Paul's advice.

Make it your character's problem.


I'm Jonathan Harden, founder of Leadership, Rehearsed, based in Belfast. Leaders and their teams rehearse the moments that matter, the hard conversation, the big presentation, the camera, with a director and a professional actor. I'm now taking a small number of founding clients: leadershiprehearsed.co.uk

Share